A comparison of story of an hour by kate chopin and the yellow wallpaper by charlotte perkins gilman

Comparative essay between the story of an hour and the yellow wall paper

He is seen to have saved her, yet what he has really done is robbed her; he has robbed her fears and therefore her opportunity to face them with courage, to grow from them, and to discover freedom and empowerment as a result; he has extinguished her unique dreams and talents, and manipulated them to his benefit. Had she been allowed personal freedom, seeing her husband would have created a happy ending. Both stories demonstrate the devastating effects on the mind and body that result from an intelligent person living with and accepting the imposed will of another. Chopin, Kate. The woman rejoices, realizing that the death of her oppressive husband means that her potential will no longer be subdued, and when she understands the news of his death to be false, she immediately perishes. Instead of dreading living a long and repressed life with her husband, she is happy with the realization that her life will be long and full of independence. She says that her soul and body are finally free. But after Louise confines herself in her room, she has a different reaction to the loss of her husband.

As she stares out the window she sees new life forming within the sky, trees and birds. As a dominate male, John sees these activities as inacceptable for the role of a woman, and it is his forced rules which worsen her condition more than anything else.

kate chopin and charlotte perkins gilman

She used her feelings to express to society how to deal with the sickness. Body and soul free! Most helpful essay resource ever!

Their use of symbolism and irony illuminate the consequence of this ongoing concern in a way that effectively communicates the severity of the issue. Jane tells of the woman in the paper creeping, and by the end of the story, Jane is creeping herself. Gilman utilizes her platform to explain the feelings of a person who suffered from a nervous depression condition. These three works differ in certain aspects, but all ultimately embody the same underlying theme of the oppression and liberation. While women have achieved equality along with political and social independence in many ways over the past century, contemporary feminist movements continue to blossom as gender expectations and stereotypes remain deeply embedded in our culture. In both stories, closed rooms are used to assist the reader in understanding private thoughts that go through the minds of the characters. The irony lies in the fact that she claims that she is finally free from the wallpaper, the object that symbolizes the mind of the insane, when really she is in a worse psychotic position than when she began her treatment. Additionally, there is irony in this situation in that her perceived freedom is only possible at the expense of her mental stability. While reflecting many similarities, these three works diverge in a few core areas, particularly in the artistic avenues and literary techniques these feminist notions are forwarded through. Check out our Privacy and Content Sharing policies for more information. It is the belief of the male physician that avoiding work and stimulation would help cure this ailment. The two stories are therefore similar in that the main characters are women who want freedom Andrea 3. The woman rejoices, realizing that the death of her oppressive husband means that her potential will no longer be subdued, and when she understands the news of his death to be false, she immediately perishes. This depicts her mental separation from herself as she now identifies with the woman in the wallpaper. The sight of him kills her.

The aura of oppression surrounding these women is soon to be mutually transformed as liberation takes its place in each of these three works. The doctors argue that her death might have been caused by the untimely sense of relief and joy she experiences after discovering that her husband is still alive.

In both stories, closed rooms are used to assist the reader in understanding private thoughts that go through the minds of the characters.

A comparison of story of an hour by kate chopin and the yellow wallpaper by charlotte perkins gilman
Rated 10/10 based on 33 review
Download
Comparing "Story of an hour "vs "The Yellow Wall Paper"